Neocolonial decoloniality?: Ontological (in)security and the Pantayong Pananaw master fantasy
Michael Magcamit discusses the key points from his new Review of International Studies article - Neocolonial decoloniality?: Ontological (in)security and the Pantayong Pananaw master fantasy
Want to know more? You can read the full article at DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0260210526102083
This is an Open Access article but BISA members receive access to RIS (and to our other journal European Journal of International Security) as a benefit of membership. To gain access, log in to your BISA account and scroll down to the 'Membership benefits' section. If you're not yet a member join today.
Abstract
This paper develops ontological security theorizing beyond its Eurocentric focus by probing the Filipino pantayong pananaw (from-us-for-us perspective) movement as a potentially decolonial intellectual and political framework. Drawing on Lacanian theorization of ontological security, I argue that pantayong pananaw can be thought of as a master fantasy that guides the desire for and quest by a formerly colonized group to become coherent, complete, and indivisible Filipinos. Amidst the inescapable ontological lack and anxiety deeply entwined with their colonial experience, the pantayong pananaw fantasy operates as a protective mechanism that promises a resolution to an original deadlock: the absence of Filipinoness. Owing to its inherently Self-versus-Other orientation, however, the pantayong pananaw fantasy inevitably imposes a closure based on a singular version of social reality aligned with an idealized vision of the Filipino identity, homeland, and nation-state. The result is neocolonial decoloniality, that is, a condition where the pursuit of intellectual and political decoloniality paradoxically creates and entrenches existing (neo)colonial structures and arrangements that perpetually marginalize certain groups within a postcolonial society. Such a dilemma has significant implications for the ethos and practice of decoloniality both as an intellectual and a political project.